[StBernard] Road Home advice fast
Westley at da-parish.com
Tue Oct 2 18:26:08 EDT 2007
Regarding your question of taxes on your Road Home funds, here are the
facts. The Road Home award will be taxable only to the extent that you
claimed a casualty loss deduction related to Katrina your any previous tax
The logic here is simple. You had the benefit of reducing your taxable
income by the amount of the financial loss you incurred due to the storm.
This cut the taxes you paid by the amount of your loss times your income tax
bracket. If you were in the 15% bracket and had a loss of $50,000, you
reduced your taxes by $7,500.
If subsequently, you receive funds that in essence reduce the financial loss
you incurred, you should pay the tax on the amount by which your loss is
reduced. If you receive $125,000 from Road Home to reimburse you for your
casualty losses (plus some), then at the end of the day, you suffered no
loss. If you didn't suffer a loss, you are not entitled to the tax savings
you took earlier and simply need to pay it back.
As for your thoughts of not taking the award so you don't have to pay taxes
on it, that doesn't make any sense. First off, I believe (and I am not a
CPA-check with one) that what's taxable is limited to the amount you claimed
as a casualty loss. In the case where you had taken a $50,000 casualty loss
and received $125,000 in Road Home award, only $50,000 of the award would be
taxable. Assuming you had to pay back the $7,500 you saved in taxes, you'd
still be ahead $117,500. To pass up $117,500 so you don't have to pay
$7,500 in taxes doesn't make sense.
It sounds to me like you have a cash flow problem. It sounds like you took
the tax savings and spent it (probably to keep you head above water) and
also took out an SBA loan. The SBA's going to get your Road Home award and
you won't have the funds to pay back the taxes you saved earlier. The good
news is that the amount you owe the SBA will be reduced by the amount of
your Road Home award. The bad news is that you will have to come out of
pocket with the funds to pay the taxes.
The SBA will recalculate your payment if you pay down a large amount of your
loan. Have you considered 1) taking out a loan to pay the taxes you owe,
and 2) repaying the loan using the funds you save by having your monthly
note reduced? Paying down your SBA loan by $125,000 should reduce your note
by about $500 a month. You do the math to figure out how many $500 monthly
payments it will take to pay off the loan you used to pay your taxes. I
suspect you'll have the loan paid off in less than a year.
The bottom line is that everyone's situation is unique. My recommendation
is that you consult with a qualified tax professional before turning down
> I have a Road Home question that I know someone from the List can help me
> with. I need a "fact" not "I think" --
> If I'm receiving Road Home money but I have a SBA loan the money goes to
> SBA, correct? Does this mean I will have to pay the taxes at the end of
> the year out of my pocket? If I do, I may be the first person to tell the
> Road Home no thank you, keep your money because I will have to pay 35% of
> $125,000.00 out of my own pocket. And less not forget the social security
> taxes I will have to pay on that. Oh this is getting worse. I need
> advice from someone that knows the facts.
> Trying to go back home
More information about the StBernard