[Slowhand] WOW, Mark...........

[david.gourlay at hrsdc-rhdcc.gc.ca]

I am certainly on board with some general guidelines in terms of relevancy of posts and stuff like that. However, I also think that we should have the freedome to post what we think is relevant and interesting to the group. One thing I personally cannot stand is people who come on here and post EBAY links of EC material they are selling or offer to sell stuff directly. I don't mind the constant posts for trades or offers of CD's - that is all part of being in this community. I don't think it is something to be critical of. However, let's establish some parameters and we can see how they go. 

I am also happy to contribute to the effort.

d

-----Original Message-----
From: ToeKneeF [mailto:slowhandnj at comcast.net] 
Sent: 2004-08-18 8:44 AM
To: Slowhand List; almighty_geetarz at yahoo.com
Cc: slowhand-owner at planet-torque.com
Subject: [Slowhand] WOW, Mark...........


  ......you definitely fired a broadside and a well deserved one it was 
too. Our group is definitely slacking when it comes to self-policing. As 
you said, we are ALL responsible and only we can set the level of 
expectation for others to follow. I read SD #s 453-456, all together, 
earlier this morning, and I was struck by the first response to your 
message. It was an attempt to justify the very behavior that you had so 
eloquently condemned! This got me to thinking about what made our group 
different from others. I would have to guess that our group is comprised 
of folks who are pretty much the same as other music groups. Why then 
this large disconnect between it's members. I could only surmise that 
perhaps we might need an FAQ to establish standards and govern our 
behavior when interacting on the SD. Most of the Newsgroups and Fan 
Groups that I have visited have an FAQ to establish resonable 
expectations of participant behavior. The SD, on the other hand, is more 
like the wild west, pretty much anything goes. Yes, many of us already 
have a good idea of what the standards are in the trading community, but 
a great deal of our members obviously don't. Its hard to enforce 
standards that are assumed. If we establish trading standards and hold 
our members accountable, we can't help but improve trading behavior.

Mark, your frustration came through LOUD AND CLEAR in your message. I 
must add, though, that your contribution to the SD community is 
invaluable. Any retreat from full participation, on your part, 
diminishes the SD. As I read your message, I found myself looking in a 
mirror, because I myself am guilty of some of the transgressions you cited.

Maybe it's time we realize that the SD has grown significantly since the 
Fish days and we need to  establish guidelines. I would be willing to 
offer my services in any capacity (input, research, compiling, editing, 
whatever) to work with other like minded SD members to establish an SD 
FAQ. Dave has done a fantastic job of keeping the SD alive, and now the 
members need to step up to the plate as well. Hopefully Dave will concur 
and sanction this effort.

Thoughts, ideas????????

-- 
"Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we.
   They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country
   and our people, and neither do we".......George W. Bush